I'm in
Home › Journal › Big Sugar, Phosphorus & the Poisoning of the Everglades
2026-06-06 · Jim

Big Sugar, Phosphorus & the Poisoning of the Everglades

Big Sugar, Phosphorus & the Poisoning of the Everglades

If drainage was how we broke the Everglades' plumbing, phosphorus is how we poisoned what's left. The story of "Big Sugar" and the Everglades Agricultural Area is the most politically charged chapter in the whole saga — and it's still being written. Here are the facts, kept straight.

A farm the size of a small state, right where the water used to flow

South of Lake Okeechobee sits the Everglades Agricultural Area (EAA) — roughly 1,100 square miles of sugarcane, vegetables, and sod, planted squarely on the path water once took south into the Glades. Farming here means fertilizing here, and fertilizer means phosphorus. By some estimates, on the order of 80 tons of phosphorus a year has run off these fields into the surrounding wetlands.

Why a little phosphorus is a big deal

The natural Everglades is a low-nutrient system — its sawgrass prairies and algal mats evolved on almost no phosphorus. Dump nutrients in and you flip the whole ecology: native algae communities collapse, cattail chokes out sawgrass, open-water feeding areas vanish, and harmful algae blooms take over. Those blooms cause fish kills, have been tied to manatee deaths, and can even help microbes concentrate toxins like mercury. Water quality in the Everglades has been degrading from farm and stormwater runoff since the 1960s — and in 1988 the federal government sued the state of Florida over EAA phosphorus damaging Everglades National Park.

The cost is real money, not just scenery

This isn't only an environmental line item. Harmful algal blooms fed by this nutrient load were estimated to cost Florida's economy about $2.7 billion in 2018 alone — in lost tourism, fishing, real estate, and public health. Cleanup — through massive treatment marshes called Stormwater Treatment Areas — has made progress, but by many accounts it's still not keeping up.

Where an overlander lands on this

I'm not here to demonize farmers. I'm here to tell the truth about the water I drive through: it carries whatever we put upstream. The phosphorus story connects directly to the Lake Okeechobee discharges and to the restoration fight trying to fix all of it.

See the real Everglades →

Sources

BYOD · Bring Your Own Defender

Would you bring your Defender to Naples?

Add your name and email to the interest list for a BYOD Defender Party near Naples, Florida. Nothing is booked yet. If enough of you are in, we plan it together.

Count me in